Frequently Asked Questions
Why do I need an appraisal?
Appraisals of personal property are compiled for a number of reasons: for insurance purposes, for donation to a non-profit or other organization, and for estate and property liquidation, to name the most common situations. Sometimes an appraisal is requested simply out of curiosity.
We typically recommend getting an appraisal for an item (or items) that have a value or combined value of over $3,000. The IRS requires a qualified appraisal for any donated item (or grouping of similar items) equal to or exceeding $5,000.*
Do all appraisers have similar qualifications?
No. Appraising is a professional discipline with unique criteria for appraisers to be considered “qualified.” There are many who call themselves appraisers who have not completed any formal training or education in the subject of appraisal theory, methodology, and report writing standards. Always look for an appraiser with an accreditation or certification within one of the three recognized appraisal organizations - The International Society of Appraisers (ISA), The American Society of Appraisers (ASA), or the Appraisers Association of America (AAA) - to ensure your appraisal will be properly researched, credible, and written to the current standards. Stefanie Miller, founder of Miller Appraisals, holds an “AM” Accredited Member status from the ISA.
How does the appraisal process work?
The appraisal process starts with a phone or email discussion to determine your particular appraisal needs. We will then schedule a time for a meeting and evaluation of the items to be appraised. Some appraisals can be completed through high quality photographs sent through email or even through Zoom.
The client should prepare for the appraisal by having all items to be appraised accessible. It is helpful for objects to be on tables (if items are small) and in well-lit rooms. We will also ask for any background information you have of the objects, including any family stories, previous paperwork or bills of sale, etc. During the consultation and evaluation, all items will be measured and photographed.
Following the evaluation, we will conduct market research to find comparables of the object(s) in the appraisal. We have subscriptions to a number of databases and auction results that help us find accurate value opinions.
What types of value do appraisers use to value items?
There are several types of value that can be used for appraisals, and the type depends on the specific needs of the client and what they intend to do with the appraised item(s). For example, there can be:
Replacement Cost: The highest monetary value given to an item if it needs to be replaced. Used for insurance purposes.
Fair Market Value: The amount an item would sell for in a willing sale between buyer and seller, neither being forced to buy or sell; also known as "open market" value. Items typically sell for fair market value at local consignment shops, auctions, etc. Used for valuations of property for Donation and Estate purposes.
Liquidation/Wholesale Value: The amount a dealer would pay for an item, typically up to 50% less than the item's retail value.
* Information on value sourced from Trusted Choice Insurance Providers.
Why can't you just tell me what my items are worth?
We provide appraisal reports, which are formal - sometimes legal - documents required in many cases for insurance and estate purposes. In paying for an appraisal, you are paying for the appraiser to research the appropriate market for your item(s) and to give you a professional and informed opinion of value.
What kinds of things will you appraise?
We are qualified to do appraisals for personal property of many types - that means we can appraise typical things found in a household such as furniture, fine art, china, or silver, or more unique items like historical memorabilia. We currently DO NOT appraise wine or stamps.
How do I know if something I have is worth appraising?
This question is best answered after a free email or phone discussion. After that we can determine if an appraisal of your item(s) is in your best interests.
Will you offer to buy the items I am having appraised?
No, we will not offer to buy anything that we are appraising. This is considered a conflict of interest. Be wary of appraisers that offer to buy or broker your items after you receive a valuation from them.
What does an appraisal cost?
See our page "Terms and Fee Structure" for information about appraisal costs.
Will you authenticate my painting or other item?
With rare exceptions, appraisers are not qualified to authenticate and should turn to the recognized expert or experts when in doubt about authenticity. Recognized scholars are usually art historians, dealers, or close family members expressly familiar with the work of an artist. Occasionally, there are circumstances that will require authentication, including: when a work has a potentially high value and its authenticity is in question, when historical significance is a factor in valuation, or when correct attribution of the work is required for the appraisal’s purpose (as in the case with noncash charitable contribution).
Can you guarantee that my items will sell for the appraised values?
Unfortunately, no. Appraised values are a thoroughly researched opinion, but they are not a warranty that the items will realized appraised value if offered for sale at auction, estate sale, or by any other means.
What will I receive for the cost of the appraisal?
After the research and documentation is completed, we will provide you with a digital, PDF copy of your appraisal report. Paper copies of reports can be printed for an additional fee.
*Please note that we provide appraisals only - we do not offer legal advice. It is advised that you consult an attorney or tax professional with any legal questions, and have these questions answered before you obtain an appraisal.